Just jabbed my friend Harry a little by pointing out that some still refer to the Bull Run battles as the Battles of 1st and 2nd Manassas, respectively. It was all in good fun, and owe a hat tip to Harry for pointing out that there are some quality Civil War stamps on the horizon… and not the cartoon-like images we saw a few years ago.
Actually, the First Bull Run (Manassas) stamp caught my attention because of my personal connection… with some of the people who would have been in the overall picture of the taking of those guns at 1st Manassas/Bull Run (hey, I can do that, as I had people on both sides in that battle… albeit those in gray far outnumbered the one kinsman in blue that was there).It’s what we see in the Sydney King’s print from 1964 that stirs me. You see, just to the right, though you can’t see it, the 33rd Virginia has taken Griffin’s guns (actually, at this particular moment in this scene, they were probably in the midst of reforming, having been repulsed). Yes, the boys from the 33rd “got their dander up”. As Ricketts told it, Griffin’s guns were a little to the rear on his right. The 33rd took Griffin’s two howitzers between 2 and 3:30 p.m. It was a bit of a mess, but, from what I recall from various sources, the 33rd (as I indicated) was repelled about the time, or slightly before, the rest of Jackson’s brigade moved against Rickett’s guns… and this is what we are seeing in King’s painting… the precious seconds before the 2nd, 4th, 5th, and 27th Virginia Infantry swallowed-up Rickett’s guns.
In that assault on Griffin’s guns, I had many an uncle and cousin. The most senior in rank among these kinsmen was Michael Shuler, a a teenage lieutenant, who had hardly completed his first part-time term at Roanoke College. He wouldn’t turn 18 until almost two months after 1st Manassas. He was one of the more fortunate kin, as he walked away from the taking of Griffin’s guns without a physical wound. Another uncle, Martin Van Buren Koontz, wasn’t as fortunate. He was mortally wounded at the guns. At the ripe old age of 21, he died on July 23. I suspect his brother, 29-year-old George William Koontz, also of Co. H, 33rd Virginia, saw to it that his brother’s remains made it home to be placed in the family cemetery, near Columbia Bridge, in Page County.
Of the same company, Peter Sours recalled (in April 1914)…
Our mess consisted of Paul Miller, Peter Sours, Philip Lucas, Siram Printz, Irenus Printz, Silas Somers, all neighborhood boys of Valleyburg, formed one mess, and at the first battle of Manassas, we were drawn in line of battle in a pine thicket near the top of the hill, a battery on the flat was playing on us. Before we charged, a ball came along bounding on the ground and caught Paul Miller in the lower leg. We were ordered forward and charged the battery, where I was wounded. Philip Lucas was shot in the head at the battery, Siram Printz was killed near the battery. Silas Somers was wounded in the thigh. Irenus Printz only one escaped.
In fact, no other battle in the war brought more sorrow to the folks of Page County than 1st Manassas. More were killed or mortally wounded in that one day, than in any other single day of the war. Co. H (Page Grays) bore most of the brunt, while Co. K (Page Volunteers), 10th Virginia Infantry (see here, here, and here), saw some losses that day as well. I’m of the opinion, that because of their action that day, in quite possibly being in the spearhead that took Griffin’s guns, they were “rewarded” with the esteemed post of regimental color company for almost the balance of the war. A sense of pride, yes, but also a prime target for enemy fire… as losses in the coming years would prove.
So, does this image give me a little thrill? Darn skippy it does. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve walked along that pine thicket imagining what they thought… followed by a walk toward Griffin’s gun position, imagining the blood of my kinsmen that made the blades of grass red that day.
But, “through the eyes of my people”? To a point. As anyone who reads this blog probably realizes, I often take-on history through the “eyes of my people”, but I think I know when and where to hold back. To me, my ancestors offer “insertion points” in historical moments. Genealogy is actually what led me to my passion for history (even before my teenage years). After all, my people were at some places where some pretty amazing stuff took place, and I don’t mind telling anyone that I find it pretty awesome that I can trace back to these distant cousins, uncles, grandfathers, who bore witness to the events on many a battlefield. Yet, I can’t don their experience as my own. I can’t don their feelings like an overcoat, at any particular moment, as my own. I can’t don the “causes” behind which they rallied (and the various reasons they did… voluntarily or reluctantly), as my own. Their time, their world, their context was their own. I am not (and hence, another inspiration behind today’s post… thanks Brooks) a Confederate (although I have been known to play one from time to time 🙂 ); they were Confederates… but even that is complicated.
Studying my people at these places, and the world around them, as they may have seen it… it all gives me things to contemplate… to consider. I have no right to think, at any time, that I know what they thought and what they felt, and that what they felt and thought is my path for action in life. I can only imagine… and it’s enough of a thrill for me.
All that said… I want to also take time to wish everyone a very happy New Year! I think we’re about to have an incredible journey in the upcoming Sesquicentennial.
Mike Musick
December 31, 2010
Happy New Year to you, too, Robert! Keep up the great blogging. Regarding Michael Shuler, I got a kick out of seeing the reference to Roanoke College – I’m class of ’66.
Robert Moore
December 31, 2010
Hi Mike! Thanks! Yes, Shuler matriculated in August 1860 as a “Partial Course” student. In fact, another future Page County Confederate, Benjamin Franklin Grove, matriculated at the same time and was also enrolled as a partial student. The full ten-month session was cut short by Virginia casting her lot with the Confederacy, in April. Both returned home shortly thereafter.
Craig Swain
December 31, 2010
Happy New Year, Robert. For next year, let’s pick one of these battlefields and walk it through from end to end, what say?
Robert Moore
December 31, 2010
I’m certainly in need of a good battlefield walk! Haven’t enjoyed a full-blown walk like that in years.
Sherree
January 2, 2011
“All that said… I want to also take time to wish everyone a very happy New Year! I think we’re about to have an incredible journey in the upcoming Sesquicentennial.”
Happy New Year to you, too, Robert. It should be a darn skippy year for sure! (lol, love that phrase. Also, great post.)
Robert Moore
January 2, 2011
Hi Sherree! Always good to hear from you!
Susan Evelyn McDowell Cole
January 22, 2011
Good to hear you like Harry. I have been following his blog for while. Of course I am a McDowell and am probably related to General Irvin McDowell. But I will follow your post for awhile and see where it leads me.
Susan Evelyn McDowell Cole
Robert Moore
January 22, 2011
Thanks for following, Susan! Hope you enjoy… and please, feel free to comment.
Michael Brooks
April 29, 2013
Hello, great piece. What’s your source for the Peter Sours material? I’d like to read more of that. Thanks!
Robert Moore
April 30, 2013
Thanks. Peter Sours was referenced in the source as he appears here. It didn’t expand further beyond that.
Betty Sours Cslder
April 30, 2013
I was very excited to read the quote by Peter Sours. He was my great grandfather. I love finding new things on the internet. You have had a great blog for years on the Civil War. Thank you for finding so much. Betty Sours Calder, GA
Robert Moore
May 1, 2013
Thank you, Ms. Csider. Glad you enjoy!
Greg Sours
June 7, 2013
Mr Moore,
I’ve been doing a little research lately and found out that Peter Sours was my Great Great Grandfather. I came across your blog, and would love to know the source from which the recalling of my Great Great Grandfather came. Thank you.
Robert Moore
June 8, 2013
Thanks for commenting, Greg,
The snippet comes from a collection of papers that belonged to F.T. Amiss. He spent a considerable amount of time compiling a list of all of those from Page County who fought in the war. Sours’ recollection was part of that, but there isn’t any more than that from Sours in the papers.
Alice Marie Sours Spivey
January 5, 2014
Here it is yet another New Year when I am reading your very interesting article. My sister (Betty Sours Calder, above) told me about it but I am just now checking it out.
However, I am not only interested in Peter Sours, my great grandfather, but the Moores.
My grandmother was a Moore from Rappahannock Co. who married a Sours from Page Co.
and I have ancestors and a current cousin named Robert Moore. Could this mean anything?
I enjoy current as well as past connections to “my people”
I hope I am not being too nosy.
Alice M. Sours Spivey
Robert Moore
January 5, 2014
Hmmm… no connection to that Moore, but I do have ties to another Moore who married a Sours.