“‘It would have pleased you to know and have heard the wild rebel yell echoing from the ancient walls of Manila, the son of a Virginia Confederate informed former Confederate general E.P. Alexander after the war [Spanish-American War]. ‘We of the younger generation owe you of ’61 a debt of gratitude and admiration for the noble examples & high ideals set for us to follow, he continued. ‘I know that the spirit of the fathers is in the sons too, through my own limited experience in military service.’ In its battles, the First Tennessee Regiment ‘maintained the name given it in bloody baptism in the Army of Northern Virginia.’ The irony of putting down rebels with a rebel yell seemed lost on these soldiers. For them, the Confederate soldier exemplified only martial courage and discipline.'”
How could it have been anything more in the way of remembrance of a Confederate past, especially while under the flag of their fathers’ former enemy… and while wearing a blue uniform?
Dick Stanley
August 24, 2010
American soldiers (and sailors, I expect, but don’t know for sure) have been yelling and waving Stars & Bars in American wars ever since, ignoring the irony, embracing the reconciliation. To the extent anything ever was reconciled.
Robert Moore
August 25, 2010
Yes, but doing so when their fathers, the Confederate vets, were still around, and were still reflecting on actual memory of the CW… that’s significant stuff.
Robert Moore
August 25, 2010
I should clarify… I’m talking about the sons and grandsons and their enthusiasm at that time. As for the Stars and Bars among Southerners as US soldiers / sailors in wars prior to WW2, I don’t think I’ve seen evidence anywhere that this was going on.
.
Richard Williams
August 26, 2010
Very interesting Robert. Here’s an image of the Battle Flag “flown” by a WWII soldier:
http://www.ww2incolor.com/us-marines/PICT4908.html
I’ve seen others, as well as quite a few during Vietnam and the Gulf and Iraq wars.
Richard Williams
August 26, 2010
On a related note, let’s not forget the various military bases, destroyers, subs, etc named after Confederate officers.
Robert Moore
August 26, 2010
U know some Boomer subs got Lee’s and Jackson’s names, but destroyers? Just battle names among those.
Robert Moore
August 26, 2010
I know.. not U know. .. sorry