Update, 2/20/14: Please see the additional data gathered about three of the men lost, at the end of the post.
While outside my normal “theater of operations”, I felt a bit obligated to write something about the Hunley, today. Obviously, today marks the 150th anniversary of the Confederacy’s great achievement in submarine history… but also the loss of the vessel that was behind it.
As a qualified submariner, I don’t think I can miss marking the day. Furthermore, I did, after all, make a point of being present for the funeral of the crew members of the Hunley, in April, 2004. Yet, with all of the effort made on the part of identifying the Hunley‘s crew members, I decided (especially after a side conversation with blogging pal, Craig Swain… see his post on the Hunley–Housatonic incident, here) instead to focus on the men of the Housatonic. If you take a look at what’s available on the crew members lost on both ships, I think many will agree there is a void that needs to be addressed.
First, who were the five men lost?
A day after the sinking, the following report was made by Captain Green, commanding USS Canandaigua:
SIR: I have respectfully to report that a boat belonging to the Housatonic reached this ship last night at about 9:20, giving me information that that vessel had been sunk at 8:45 p. m., by a rebel torpedo craft.
I immediately slipped our cable and started for her anchorage, and on arriving near it, at 9:35, discovered her sunk with her hammock nettings under water; dispatched all boats and rescued from the wreck 21 officers and 129 men.
There are missing, and supposed to be drowned, the following-named officers and men:
Ensign Edward C. Hazeltine, Captain’s Clerk Charles O. Muzzey, Quartermaster John Williams, Second-Class Fireman John Walsh, Landsman Theodore Parker.
Captain Pickering is very much, but not dangerously, bruised, and one man is slightly bruised.
I have transferred to the Wabash 8 of her officers and 49 men, on the account of the limited accommodations on board of this vessel.
Very respectfully, your obedient servant,
J. F. GREEN,
Captain.Commodore S. C. ROWAN,
Commanding Officer off Charleston, S. C.
Since I decided to do this rather suddenly, this turned into a quick exercise (emphasis on quick) in research. Regretfully, there are limitations to doing this research strictly via computer, and a better sketch of all five men just isn’t going to unfold in this post. Still, time spent on doing this did prove satisfying. I especially found it rewarding to take nothing more than the names of men, and spend time trying to know better who they were… even if I was only able to better “know” a couple of them.
First off, some of the names proved challenging. After all, consider the common names of “John Williams” and “John Walsh”. I didn’t think, however, that “Theodore Parker” would be difficult… but it was as well. Given more time, I might do a little better.
So, we’re down to two of the five… Muzzey and Hazeltine. I’ll give some additional info on Hazeltine first. His story, though still falling short of the bio sketch I’d like to see, yielded material rather quickly.
Born ca. 1842, in New Hampshire, Edward C. Hazeltine was a son of Life A. and Caroline R. Hazeltine. On September 22, 1859, he was appointed as a midshipman with the U.S. Naval Academy. When the census was taken in 1860 (June 30), he was at home, in Concord, and was listed as present with the family…
On May 9, 1861, Edward was among the 42 members of the Second Class, of the USNA, who were ordered “detached” to active service. Young Midshipman Hazeltine appears to have seen service first aboard the USS Hartford , and later aboard the Housatonic… though I don’t have specific dates. Though I can’t say for sure on which ship he was serving at the time, he was commissioned to ensign on December 27, 1862. I wish I knew more of the details of his service, prior to his death on February 17, 1864.
The story of Clerk Muzzey, on the other hand, bore fruit a little differently. I didn’t find his information through the same resources used for Hazeltine, but through the pension application submitted by his mother (on August 22, 1864), Elizabeth. What follows below is the first page of her application (broken into segments for better resolution):
The application file also included this certificate of death, signed by the Housatonic‘s assistant surgeon:
Despite Elizabeth Muzzey’s claim, the pension board needed more information regarding her dependence on her son’s income and proof of the death of her husband. By 1867, she had provided part of what was needed (*note the reference to Nathaniel P. Banks, then a representative to Congress)…
For whatever reason, Elizabeth Muzzey apparently never provided proof of her dependence on her son. She died in 1873, with the pension application still pending.
To the sailors on both the Hunley and the Housatonic who lost their lives on this day, an often used Navy salute… “Sailors, Rest your Oars”.
There is a port of no return, where ships
May ride at anchor for a little space
And then, some starless night, the cable slips,
Leaving an eddy at the mooring place…
Gulls, veer no longer. Sailor, rest your oar.
No tangled wreckage will be washed ashore.
Addendum: Just as curious about the recovery of the Housatonic as the recovery of the Hunley? See this site, via the Naval History & Heritage Command for more.
UPDATE, 2/20/2014 – The following additional information about three of the five men lost was obtained from the article from the New York Times, and, in the case of Parker, some information gleaned from his service record:
Williams – “…had got safely on deck, but ventured back to save $300, which he had in his bag on the berth-deck. Poor fellow, he never returned.”
Welsh – “coal-heaver, of Boston”
Parker – “(colored) who was on the lookout directly over where the ship was struck, was blown into the air and instantly killed.” Age 24, 5’7”, Born in NY, NY. Enlisted 5/22/1862, for two years.
jimrada
February 18, 2014
I’ve got a book on the Hunley that I haven’t ready yet. You gave me a nudge to move it to the top of my “to read” list.
Chris Van Blargan
February 18, 2014
Theodore Parker information
http://www.nps.gov/civilwar/search-sailors-detail.htm?sailors_id=Par0063
Chris Van Blargan
February 19, 2014
Some more info:
Robert Moore
February 19, 2014
Thanks, Chris!
mionsiog
August 14, 2014
Thank You for this posting.
I saw a documentary on “H. L. Hunley”; the forensic work being done to find out why it sunk. This doc. led me to build a tree for all the persons involved in the making and deploying of the submarine. I am in the process of filling in the USS Housatonic information and your post really helps my task. I am building the tree on Ancestry.com so if you have access to the web site here is the link: http://trees.ancestry.com/tree/72121756/family. The tree name is: The crewmen of the Hunley 1863 Family Tree. If you do not have access I can give you access using your e-mail address.
mionsiog
August 14, 2014
Robert,
I found records of the five men’s deaths.
USS Housatonic – crew men who died 17 Feb 1864
USS Housatonic was sunk by the Confederate submarine “H. L. Hunley”.
Edward C. Hazeltine (Hazelton) – Ensign
[Found in records as Hazelton in the first part of books reserved for officers]
Charles O. Muzzey – Captain’s Clerk
[Found in records]
John Williams – Quartermaster
[Found in records]
John Walsh – Second-Class Fireman
[Found in records]
Theodore Parker – Landsman
[Found in records]
Ancestry.com records:
U.S., Navy Casualties Books, 1776-1941
Officers and Enlisted Men (Volume 1 and Volume 2), 1776-1885
Thank You.
Jose from Clarkston, Michigan
mionsiog
August 14, 2014
Robert,
I found two (2) family trees which have Edward C Hazeltine (Hazelton – Haseltine)’s family branch with records to confirm the relationship. With a name like “Life A.” it is easy to find and confirm records. In your post you have a screen print of 1860 census, well I found that Edward is listed on two 1860 records. He is (as you show) listed at home and he is also listed as a cadet at Annapolis. Also here are two records you might be interested in having:
New Hampshire, Births and Christenings Index, 1714-1904
Name: Life Augustus Haseltine
Birth Date: 23 Jan 1811
Birth Place: Salem, Rockingham, New Hampshire, United States
Gender: Male
Father’s Name: Nathaniel Haseltine
Mother’s name: Betsey
FHL Film Number: 1001005
===============================
1850 United States Federal Census
Name: L A Hazelton
Age: 39
Birth Year: abt 1811
Birthplace: New Hampshire
Home in 1850: Concord, Merrimack, New Hampshire
Gender: Male
Family Number: 1598
Household Members:
Name Age
L A Hazelton 39
Caroline Hazelton 40
George A Hazelton 13
Edward C Hazelton 8
Frank Hazelton 3
Eugene S Hazelton 0
————————–
I will be putting these records on to the tree I created along with all the other verifiable information for the five men who died on the USS Housatonic.
Thank You again for the posting.
Jose from Clarkston, Michigan
mionsiog
August 16, 2014
Robert,
As I mentioned in my previous messages, I created a tree for “The Hunley” and included “USS Houstantionic” information. I was able to find other tree owners who had crew members of the “USS H.” on their branches. Here is an answer from one of the tree owners.
“Subject: Charles Otis Muzzy
I have heard from another researcher who relays that” Charles entered the Navy as secretary to Capt. Pickering of the USA Kerrsarge, and was transferred to the Houstantionic May 1863. He was killed by an explosion by a torpedo in Charleston Harbor destroying his ship 18 Feb. 1964. She speculates that she may have gotten this from me, but there are details here I do not have. I looked on Google and found information, but I would guess you are way ahead of me looking at that source. This may not help, but one never knows what will help. Betty”
===========================
The Tree Name, Owner and Link to Betty’s tree on Ancestry.com
Tipton, Muzzy, Shewbridge, Carey, Riley, White, Adams Families
Owner: BettyTipton80
http://trees.ancestry.com/tree/51463991/person/13204366245
===========================
Thank You.
Jose from Clarkston, Michigan
Robert Moore
August 17, 2014
Thanks for all the additional data, Jose! I’m sure it will be much appreciated by those in search of greater details.
mionsiog
September 11, 2014
Robert,
I am working on Theodore Parker on the tree and the information you have at the end of your blog is not the same Theodore that I found. I used the “Find a Civil War Sailor” that Chris provided and I got two results for Theodore Parker who served on Housatonic.
The one born in NY (as you have) served
Sep 10, 1862 Housatonic
Jan 1, 1863 Housatonic
but the other one born Lewiston , Delaware served
Oct 1, 1864 Housatonic
Oct 1, 1863 Wabash
Oct 1, 1863 Housatonic
Since the ship was sunk on Feb 1864 I think the person who died was the Theodore Parker who was born in Delaware.
Let me know if you have other data to confirm your NY Theodore. In the mean time I will put the Delaware information on the tree and see what other records come my way.
Thank You.
Jose from Clarkston, Michigan
Joseph Thiell
February 13, 2017
I am wondering what happened to the bodies of the dead sailors, were they recovered?
Thomas Ferraiolo
July 4, 2017
I am looking for the crew list of the 42 members of the USS Housatonic 1864, supposedly my wife’s relative was aboard.
mionsiog
August 29, 2017
Thomas Ferraiolo – I have the list of dead but not full crew list — Edward C. Hazeltine (Hazelton)
Ensign on board the USS Housatonic which was sunk by the Confederate submarine “H. L. Hunley”.
[Found in records as Hazelton]
Charles O. Muzzey
Captain’s Clerk on board the USS Housatonic which was sunk by the Confederate submarine “H. L. Hunley”. [Found in records]
John Williams
Quartermaster on board the USS Housatonic which was sunk by the Confederate submarine “H. L. Hunley”. [Found in records]
John Walsh
Second-Class Fireman on board the USS Housatonic which was sunk by the Confederate submarine “H. L. Hunley”. [Found in records]
Theodore Parker
Landsman on board the USS Housatonic which was sunk by the Confederate submarine “H. L. Hunley”. [Found in records]
mionsiog
August 29, 2017
Thomas Ferraiolo, I found this web page with information about the sinking but I did not see a list of names of the crew, however if you go into the page you will see several tabs to choose from and maybe one of those will get you in touch with the records dept and they might have what you need. — Naval History and Heritage Command
https://www.history.navy.mil/research/library/online-reading-room/title-list-alphabetically/s/the-sinking-of-the-uss-housatonic-by-the-submarine-css-h-l-hunley.html